EThe editors · 3 New York pizza lists — switch
The pizza map
Fifteen long-running pizzerias in three boroughs, from the pins on Eating With Ziggy’s map.
15 placesTwo or three days
1. Joe’s Pizza, Carmine StThe plain New York slice, folded, since 1975.Village & DowntownFood & drink- 2. John’s of Bleecker StreetCoal-oven pies in wooden booths. Whole pies only.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 3. Prince Street PizzaThe square pepperoni slice with the curled-up cups.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 4. RubirosaThin-crust pies; the vodka pie is the one.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 5. Scarr’s PizzaSlices made with flour they mill themselves.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 6. Village Square PizzaSquare slices in the East Village.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 7. Motorino, East VillageNeapolitan pies; try the Brussels sprouts.Village & DowntownFood & drink
- 8. Eataly FlatironNeapolitan pies inside the Italian market.Midtown & FlatironFood & drink
9. Juliana’sCoal-oven pies under the Brooklyn Bridge.BrooklynFood & drink- 10. LucaliCandlelit pies in Carroll Gardens. Put your name down early; bring your own wine.BrooklynFood & drink
- 11. Best PizzaA Williamsburg slice shop with a wood oven.BrooklynFood & drink
- 12. Paulie Gee’sNeapolitan pies in Greenpoint; the Hellboy has hot honey.BrooklynFood & drink
- 13. Roberta’s, BushwickWood-fired pies in a Bushwick garden.BrooklynFood & drink
- 14. Joe & Pat’sPaper-thin Staten Island pies.Staten IslandFood & drink
- 15. Lee’s TavernBar pies at a Staten Island tavern.Staten IslandFood & drink
Started from the pins on Eating With Ziggy’s Pizza Map (the map). Places and notes checked and written by us; opening times change, so check before you go.